A federal judge on Monday will weigh pleas by four major book publishers to stop an online lending library from freely offering digital copies of books, in a case that raises novel questions about digital-library rights and the reach of copyright law that protects the work of writers and publishers. William Adams, general counsel for HarperCollins Publishers, said the archive’s approach has no basis in law. “What they’re doing is supplanting what authors and publishers do with libraries and have been doing for a long time,” he said.
Source: Online-Books Lawsuit Tests Limits of Libraries in Digital Age
Global music publishers are officially responding to Meta’s alleged ‘strongarm tactics’ amid a licensing dispute with Italian authors. According to SIAE, the song pulldowns followed months of unsuccessful discussions with Meta, after the Instagram owner’s prior licensing deal expired at 2023’s start. SIAE further accused Meta of making a “take it or leave it” lump-sum offer without providing “the fundamental information necessary for a fair negotiation.”
Twitter explored the licensing of music rights from three major labels before negotiations stalled after Elon Musk’s takeover of the company, said eight people with knowledge of the discussions, who were not authorized to speak publicly. Twitter is one of the last big social media platforms without music licensing deals. Facebook, Instagram and TikTok have all made agreements for music rights.
This week, The Italian Society of Authors and Publishers (SIAE), which represents tens of thousands of songwriters in Italy, issued a press release announcing that US tech behemoth Meta had decided to “exclude” its music repertoire from services such as Facebook. According to SIAE, the decision to remove its members’ songs has left Italian authors and publishers “bewildered”.
On Wednesday (March 15), Universal confirmed an initiative between the two companies to “investigate potential new economic models for music streaming that more fully recognize the value artists create.” According to a press release, through this collaboration, “UMG and Deezer aim to develop new methods that holistically reward recording artists and songwriters for the value they create and to reimagine and update the engagement model for Deezer’s users and the artists they love.”
Organizations representing book publishers, booksellers and authors have formed a coalition to protect copyrights and oppose legislation across the country that it fears could drive down e-book prices and damage writers’ ability to support themselves. Their current focus is proposed legislation in Connecticut, Kentucky and elsewhere that sets boundaries on what publishers can ask for when negotiating with a given state’s library system.
A closer look at e-lending rates reveals that concern over current prices is unwarranted. While libraries often pay $50 for a two-year license permitting unlimited electronic checkouts—triple the amount readers pay per e-book with a personal license—this rate saves libraries a great deal of money in the long run. Without the pricing differences between e-lending and personal licenses, it wouldn’t make financial sense for authors to offer their works to libraries at all.