Amongst the proposals, there are documents from trade orgs representing major labels, indie labels, music publishers, songwriters, artist managers, streaming services, and others. There are also direct submissions from artists, including British pop-ska legends Madness, as well as the #brokenrecord campaign that’s caught momentum on social media these past few months.
Source: BMG, Beggars Group and Hipgnosis each have strong opinions on streaming. Here are those opinions.


The U.K.’s three biggest record label heads put on a united front at a Parliamentary probe into the streaming business on Tuesday (Jan. 19), denying artist claims that music streaming payouts are unfairly weighted in labels’ favor. The label executives stressed the importance of protecting artists’ interests and maximizing revenue for all parties.
The US government is asking Australia to abandon a proposed law that would force Facebook and Google to pay local media firms a cut of the advertising revenue they rake in when using their content. American trade representatives Daniel Bahar and Karl Ehlers asked Australia to “suspend” the plans and suggested the country instead “further study the markers, and if appropriate, develop a voluntary code.”
In response to a lawsuit filed by YouTube-ripping service Yout, the RIAA is doubling down on its assertion that YouTube’s rolling cipher is indeed an “effective technological measure” under the DMCA. The music industry group also states that seeking remedy for improper takedown notices under the DMCA is not possible since the relevant law does not penalize anti-circumvention complaints.
The Antitrust Division has considered carefully stakeholders’ views on all of these issues and recognizes that continuing disagreements exist among artists and within the music community regarding the benefits, drawbacks, and continued need for the ASCAP and BMI consent decrees. Continued review of, and stakeholder input concerning, the decrees remains necessary to ensure the decrees continue to satisfy their purpose to protect competition and do not act as an impediment to innovation.
The Dept. of Justice has ended its ASCAP/BMI consent decree review without taking action, meaning agreements governing PROs will continue to exist as they have. The DOJ’s assistant Attorney General for the Antitrust Division Makan Delrahim revealed that decision Friday (Jan. 15) in a webinar sponsored by the Vanderbilt Law School.
There has been an interesting development in the way that Google handles DMCA anti-circumvention notices sent by the RIAA. These have been used dozens of times by the music industry group to have YouTube-ripping platforms removed from Google search. Since the controversy over youtube-dl, however, Google appears to be rejecting similar complaints.